Facebook Engraving Challenge
The Music Engraving Tips
group on Facebook recently featured an engraving challenge
for replicating this score
Here is our result created from scratch in just 20 minutes
starting with Finale's default document.
Download the final PDF score
Download Finale's output before applying the plugins
Download the Finale musx document
Video: 20 minute live stream of the whole engraving process
3rd party Finale plugins used:
-Elbsound.studio's Perfect Layout
for optimizing all other layout issues (not available yet to the public, beta test only).
-Elbsound.studio's House Style
for changing the style of the score (not available yet).
-Elbsound.studio's Scale Systems for scaling the page and staff systems to an optimal size (not available yet).
for running the Elbsound.studio plugins.
for beam optimization
Compress Spacing for compressing the spacing of the 7-tuplet.
Keyboard Remapper for quick access to the main Finale tools (see screenshot below
for my setup).
Other helpers used:
for faster navigation in Speedy Entry and Scroll View (see below
for my setup)
-The document uses Lilypond's free Gonville
font for the musical symbols (and the Elbsound font GnvilFIN
for the rest symbols) and the free TeX Gyre Schola
-Foxit PDF printer
Normally I also use a Logitech G13
for more complex Finale operations (especially parts layout, edit filter automation and playback muting), but it was not necessary here.
Differences to the original document
from the challenge:
- the tuplets in my document use a more standard placement (usually on the stem side)
- the bracket on the timpani staff is missing (Gould says it is optional to have a group bracket on the timpani staff)
- Finale's consolidated rests in measure 4 oboe are probably not ideal here (the original is better!): to solve this open the Edit Frame dialog of this measure and uncheck "Combine Rests")
- Vln.1/Vln.2 usually have a group bracket by default. But Finale is a bit inconsistent here: why do the clarinet/bass clarinet and bassoon/contrabassoons don't have a group bracket by default.
- the spacing of the 7-tuplet in measure 2 still doesn't look quite convincing: the last space is much too small and the other spaces are too different. Probably I clicked too often on "Compress spacing".
- the single piano staff doesn't have a group bracket anymore. I prefer this look. To have the bracket visible, go to Edit Group and check "Show bracket if group contains only one staff"
- the top tuplet brackets in measure 4/oboe could be shifted slightly closer to the staff.
Image 1: The final page after 20 minutes (for PDF click on the image)
The plugins also have prepared the linked parts
in the background.
This is how the first horn part currently looks - i.e. the layout optimizations have been performed for printing, but the part names need to be edited and multiple voice staves - like the oboes - need to be split with the parts manager.
Image 2: How do the parts look after 20 minutes?
Here is a video of the same score page created live in Sibelius
(great job, Justin!).
And here is an image of the page created in Lilypond
Image 3: Setup of my TG Tools "Keyboard Remapper" tool (TGTools->Options->Keyboard Remapper)
scripts I used in this video: (more on AutoHotKey in Finale
Ctrl-Arrow Left/Right or Shift-Mouse Wheel Up/Down for jumping to the next/previous measure in Scroll View
Ctrl-Arrow Up/Down for jumping to the next octave in Speedy Entry
Remap y/z to z/y for using Speedy Entry in the English Finale version on a German keyboard